Volume vs Density: Are we asking the wrong questions about UK food security?
Nov 20, 2026

Food security is big news in the UK, but are we asking the right questions when it comes to securing the future of our food? This National Malnutrition Awareness Week, FarmED co-founder Ian Wilkinson considers if British Farming must move beyond volume as a success metric and prioritise nutritional value over all else.
Tonnes per hectare. Litres per cow. Yield per acre. Output per pound invested. For generations, we have measured the success of agriculture by how much food we can produce.
These measures have shaped agricultural policy, scientific research, farming practices, and commercial relationships throughout the food supply chain. They have driven remarkable improvements in productivity and helped create a food system capable of feeding millions of people.
But as we look towards 2050, and with the Government’s Farming Roadmap set to get us there, perhaps it is time to switch from asking ‘are we producing enough food?’ to ‘are we producing enough nutrition?’.
It’s an important distinction, and one that British agriculture and future policy makers can’t afford to overlook. We are in a period of climate volatility, soil degradation, pressure on natural resources, and geopolitical instability, all of which increasingly threatens the resilience of global food production. At the same time, emerging research is raising questions about the nutritional composition of some of the crops we depend upon here in the UK and the long-term health of the soil in which it grows.
Worst case scenario? We could find ourselves producing more food by weight, while delivering less nutritional value per kilogram. If that happens, our traditional measures of agricultural success will tell us that we are progressing, when we may in fact be moving backwards when it comes to the overall health of the population.
We currently waste around 30-40% of our food annually. Perhaps, then, the next agricultural revolution should not be about producing more food, but rather about producing nutritionally denser food. That’s what I’ve been reflecting on this National Malnutrition Awareness Week here in the UK.
Volume vs Density
Modern agriculture has been extraordinarily successful at increasing output. Scientific advances, mechanisation, fertilisers, improved crop genetics, and increasingly sophisticated production systems have transformed the capacity of British farms and the lives of British farmers.
But the incentives have largely been built around volume, efficiency, consistency, and commercial value, while the question of nutritional density has received considerably less attention.
Nutritional density, the concentration of essential nutrients within food, including protein, fibre, vitamins and minerals, is influenced by genetics, soil conditions, growing practices, climate, and harvesting and processing. It is not simply about whether food is organic, regenerative, or locally produced, nor can we assume that food grown in healthier soil will automatically contain more nutrients. It is about understanding what our agricultural systems can actually deliver in terms of human nutrition. This matters because the nutritional quality of our food supply is fundamental to both long-term public health and food security.
The UK Government's October 2026 Nutritional Supply of Agriculture statistics estimate that domestic agricultural production in 2025 was equivalent to 101% of the population's energy requirements and 194% of its protein requirements. But these figures measure the estimated nutritional contribution of production, not the nutrient density of individual foods or the nutritional quality of what people ultimately consume. While it is commendable and important that we have started measuring how much nutrition our agriculture produces, the next step should be understanding how to improve it, because the climate crisis is changing the equation.
Farming in a changing climate is not simply a question of whether we can maintain agricultural yields, but whether we can maintain the nutritional quality and reliability of food production under increasingly challenging conditions. Indeed, this year has given us a sobering taste of these challenging conditions. A recent BBC Panorama programme looking at our changing weather visited a farm that had experienced a 70% decline in its spring barley this year – clearly not sustainable.
The developing El Niño event provides another timely reminder of our exposure to climatic disruption. Its effects will be felt differently across the world's agricultural regions, but the potential for extreme weather, disrupted harvests, and international supply-chain pressure reinforces the importance of building greater resilience into domestic food production. The programme also ran a MET Office weather simulation looking at what temperatures might look like in June 2056 in the UK. The model suggested 45 degrees centigrade based on current weather patterns and modelling, clearly not a climate suitable for farming the ways we currently do.
We currently have no Minister or department responsible for food or nutritional security. Britain cannot assume that international markets will always provide a reliable alternative when major food-producing regions experience climatic shocks. We must consider not just how much food we can produce domestically, but how much essential nutrition we can reliably supply.
Soil – the missing link in the nutritional debate
At the centre of this conversation is soil. We have become increasingly aware of the importance of soil health to carbon storage, biodiversity, water management, and agricultural resilience, but we should be paying much closer attention to the relationship between soil condition, nutrient availability, and the nutritional composition of food.
Soil is a living ecosystem. Its physical structure, organic matter, microbial communities, mineral balance, and biological activity all influence how plants access and utilise nutrients. When soils are degraded, compacted, depleted or poorly managed, the consequences extend beyond reduced productivity, we risk undermining the natural systems on which the nutritional potential of our food depends.
The Farming Roadmap 2050 already recognises that healthy soils are essential to the future of British agriculture. Its commitments to soil monitoring, improved organic matter and more sustainable nutrient management are welcome. But why stop at measuring whether soil can sustain crop growth? Why not also investigate what that soil enables us to produce nutritionally?
There is a need to establish a national soil-to-nutrition research programme, linking soil monitoring with crop nutrient analysis and food composition data. This would help us understand which farming practices improve soil function, which improve the nutritional quality of harvested food, and where the two outcomes reinforce one another. It would also help farmers make better-informed decisions about the long-term value of their land and when and where to employ regenerative agricultural practices such as planting nitrogen-fixing plants like peas, beans, and clovers.
Imagine if the Farming Roadmap had nutritional density at its centre. Soil health would be considered a nutritional security priority, not simply an environmental objective. Agricultural research would be judged partly on its ability to improve the nutritional characteristics of crops, and climate adaptation would consider the protection of nutritional output, not just yield.
Government support would increasingly recognise measurable improvements in soil function, nutrient efficiency and food quality. Food manufacturers and retailers would be encouraged to reward farmers who can demonstrate the nutritional characteristics of their produce. Public procurement would place greater emphasis on the nutritional and environmental quality of British food.
And national food security assessments would consider whether we have sufficient domestic capacity to supply the nutrients needed by our population, rather than relying primarily on aggregate food production figures. The good news is that none of this requires us to abandon the progress already being made in regenerative agriculture, soil regeneration, or productivity improvement. In fact, it gives these activities a more meaningful and measurable purpose.
The Government's Good Food Cycle already recognises the need for a healthier, more affordable, sustainable and resilient food system. The opportunity is to connect those ambitions much more directly to what happens on the farm, with agriculture recognised as the starting point of national nutritional security.
A commercial opportunity for British farmers
British agriculture has the scientific expertise, research institutions and farming capability to become a leader in climate-resilient, nutrition-focused food production, but farmers must be able to capture some of the value they create.
If nutritional quality becomes increasingly important to consumers, food manufacturers, and public health, there should be a commercial mechanism for rewarding it. That means developing credible nutritional standards, investing in testing and verification, creating supply-chain partnerships, and exploring premiums for demonstrable improvements in food quality.
It also means recognising that farmers are not simply producing raw materials. They are managing the natural capital on which future food production depends. A hectare of healthy, productive agricultural land should be valued not just for its annual output, but for its ability to deliver nutritious food consistently over decades.
But perhaps the biggest change we need is a shift in farming philosophy. For too long, we have equated agricultural success with producing more. We should now be asking whether we are producing the right food, with the right nutritional characteristics, from land that is healthy enough to keep producing it.
This requires a new partnership between farmers, scientists, policymakers, manufacturers, and retailers – indeed the whole supply chain. It requires better data, different incentives, and a willingness to challenge established assumptions about productivity. Most importantly, it requires us to recognise that the purpose of agriculture is not simply to produce calories or commodities. It’s to nourish people, sustain communities, and protect the natural resources that future generations will depend upon.
The measure of successful British farming in 2050 should not simply be tonnes per hectare. It should be nutritional value per hectare, delivered sustainably, affordably, and reliably. Food production and nutritional production are not necessarily the same thing, and the future of British farming and our nutritional security depends on us understanding the difference.
Ian Wilkinson is Co-Founder and Director of FarmED, a leading centre for farming and food education at the heart of local, regional and global agroecological transitions. FarmED’s mission is to provide learning spaces and events that inspire, educate and connect people to build sustainable farming and food systems that nourish people and regenerate the planet. Its flagship event programme, Leaders in the Field, brings together leaders from the world of farming, government policy, climate science, ecology, and higher education. The events, which are by invitation only, debate the pressing issues of the climate crisis, food security, farming practices and others in the hope of facilitating impactful partnerships and real-world solutions across sectors.
Recent news items

